clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

The Other Top 25: Behind Jordan Caroline and the Martin twins, Nevada is our preseason No. 1

A stacked Gonzaga squad is right behind the Wolf Pack.

Loyola v Nevada Photo by Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images

Over the past month, we’ve revealed our preseason top 25 teams one by one, giving you some analysis on each along the way. Today, we present to you the full thing, with a breakdown of how many points each team received.

The whole thing is below, but first, a quick word on our rankings this year:

You’ve probably noticed that we’ve changed our name from The Mid-Major Madness Power Rankings to The Other Top 25. We did this because of THAT THING we’ve discussed on here and on Twitter a million times over the last few years: There’s no clear definition of what a mid-major is, but everyone knows that schools like Gonzaga do not operate like one. So it doesn’t make sense to rank them in a poll with the words “mid-major” in it. We toyed with the idea of taking them out entirely and limiting teams based on their college basketball budgets, revenues, or other guidelines, but couldn’t settle on one metric that made perfect sense. So we just changed the name to The Other Top 25. Everybody not in the Power 5, Big East, or American is still eligible.

With the goal in mind to get better at these every year, we’ve also expanded our pool of voters a little bit, ensuring we get an even wider variety of opinions.

Got all that? Good. Here are the rankings:

The Other Top 25: Preseason Rankings

RANK TEAM 2017-18 RECORD POINTS
RANK TEAM 2017-18 RECORD POINTS
1 Nevada (11) 29-8 299
2 Gonzaga (1) 32-5 288
3 South Dakota State 28-7 258
4 Loyola 32-6 254
5 BYU 24-11 237
6 Marshall 25-11 229
7 Buffalo 27-9 225
8 Davidson 21-12 212
9 San Diego State 22-11 175
10 Illinois State 18-15 168
11 Western Kentucky 27-11 138
12 UNC Greensboro 27-8 138
13 Montana 26-8 126
14 Georgia State 24-11 110
15 Saint Louis 17-16 109
16 Belmont 24-9 75
17 New Mexico 19-15 74
18 Saint Mary’s 30-6 71
19 Wofford 21-13 56
20 Rhode Island 26-8 50
21 Northeastern 23-10 46
21 North Texas 20-18 46
23 Old Dominion 25-7 40
24 Vermont 27-8 37
25 Harvard 18-14 34

The thought around college basketball seems to be that Gonzaga is better than Nevada by a hair, and it’s easy to see why: The Zags return almost their entire team from last year, when they earned a 4 seed in the NCAA Tournament, and add grad transfer and master bucket-getter Geno Crandall. They can be a Final Four team and will probably spend some time atop our rankings this year. We gave Nevada a slight — and I mean slight — edge because we think they just have more. Literally. Like, Nevada is stupid deep, between the returns of the Martwins, Jordan Caroline, some great transfers, and a five-star freshman. Perhaps our friend Eli Boettger can help you visualize exactly how deep the Wolf Pack are:

There’s a lot happening there. We’ll release our first full in-season poll next week, complete with up-to-date records, changes based on the first week of games, and others receiving votes.